Hatchbag vs Weathertech Trunk Mats: Pros & Cons

Choosing the best cargo liner for your vehicle is an important decision if you desire maximum protection for your trunk. Both Hatchbag and Weathertech sell cargo liners, that fit into the space of your trunk. Whether you simply value a clean interior or haul around groceries, hiking equipment or pets, the correct cargo liner will be provide the best protection and a tailored fit. In this blog, we’ll look at the features, materials used, and customizations offered by both companies, comparing their strengths to help you make an informed decision on the right cargo liner for you.

Overview and Key Features of the Hatchbag Cargo Liner

Hatchbag cargo liners stand out with their tailor-made fit and durability. The Hatchbag cargo liner that you order for your vehicle, will fit every curve and contour, following the trunk’s natural shape. This guarantees the ultimate protection for your vehicle’s interior. The Hatchbag cargo liner covers every inch of your trunk, ensuring that no dirt, spills and wear and tear, damage your vehicle’s interiors. Hatchbag has been designing cargo liners for cars for decades, and the process of producing these is well thought out and guarantees an amazing product. Hatchbag focusses on a robust and perfectly functioning cargo liner mixed with aesthetic appeal, making sure your vehicle looks great and is spotless.

One key feature of the Hatchbag cargo liner that makes its durability so impressive, is the material used in the manufacturing process. Hatchbag cargo liners are made from fibre reinforced PVC, a tear proof and extremely strong material. This material is also water resistant, making it ideal for users who regularly transport items that could leak or wet and smelly dogs! Hatchbag cargo liners can handle anything, and will always protect your vehicle.

One of the impressive features of the Hatchbag cargo liner is how customizable the product is. We want your cargo liner to fit seamlessly into your everyday life and what you are using your car for. Whether it’s hauling heavy equipment into the trunk or reclining your rear seats for large objects, Hatchbag’s comprehensive protection has you covered. An example of one of our extras is the bumper flap. This hangs over the bumper of the car and protects this area from damage. This is ideal for dog owners, who notice that claw marks from their pets jumping into the trunk, are damaging the area. Check out our extensive range of extras and accessories to see what you can add to your vehicle to not only maximize protection, but get the most out of your car’s functionality. The Hatchbag cargo liner also comes in a range of different colors. You can match the interior or exterior of your car, or opt for a completely different look with a vibrant pop of color. The level of customization that Hatchbag offers, ensures a fully protected vehicle with an aesthetic appeal.

Overview and Key Features of the Weathertech Cargo Liner

Weathertech also produce cargo liners that are made to fit your vehicle. The Weathertech cargo liner is limited in the protection that it can offer due to the material that is used. The cargo liners are made from thermoplastic elastomer, which has been noted to curl up in the corners and stiffen, leaving areas of your trunk unprotected. The cargo liners also only cover the base of your vehicle, leaving the sides and the back exposed to damage, wear and tear and spillages that are difficult to fully remove.

Weathertech cargo liners are durable and are manufactured with a textured surface that helps to reduce slip and slide in the trunk. However, this material can be difficult to clean, with dirt and debris lodging into the grooves and preventing a full and spotless clean. This can give the cargo liner a tired appearance in your trunk.

The Weathertech cargo liner is semi customizable, offering a bumper protector to add some more coverage to the bumper area. However, in comparison to the extensive range Hatchbag offers, this singular extra won’t add much to the protection of your car.  

Durability and Material Comparison

When it comes to comparing the materials used when making Hatchbag cargo liners and Weathertech cargo liners, both companies use durable materials. However, how the materials are specifically used in terms of design choices, massively impacts the protection of your vehicle.

Hatchbag cargo liners are made from fibre reinforced PVC, which is a water resistant material and is known for its durability. Fibre reinforced PVC is very effective in protecting your vehicle from dirt, wear and tear and spills. With the cargo liner being made from PVC, this makes our product easy to clean and easy to maintain. No machine washing required, simply wipe down your cargo liner with a damp cloth or add some soap for those particularly tough stains. This makes the Hatchbag cargo liner a great choice for users who often are faced with a wet and dirty trunk.

Weathertech cargo liners are made from a blend of thermoplastic elastomer. This material is both flexible and durable, but has limitations when acting as a cargo liner for your trunk. In high and low temperatures, the material can start to curl up in the corners, leaving gapping. This leaves your trunk exposed and susceptible to damage. Additionally, Weathertech don’t offer any form of comfort mats that cushion the cargo liner. This can lead to uncomfortable pets and materials such as glass not being protected on road trips.

In terms of the durability of the cargo liners, both Hatchbag and Weathertech liners are hard wearing. However, when choosing a cargo liner, you need to weigh up how effective the cargo liner is in protecting your trunk. We can guarantee that the Hatchbag cargo liner will protect your vehicle for as long as you have it.

Installing Your Cargo Liner: Hatchbag vs Weathertech

Installing a cargo liner needs to be a straightforward process. Additionally, when you install your cargo liner, you want it to stay in the same position, so your liner is constantly protecting your trunk. There are some differences in how you fit the Hatchbag and Weathertech cargo liners, which are important to outline, so you make the best decision for your vehicle.

The Hatchbag cargo liners are a tailor-made product that seamlessly fit your vehicle’s interior. In every cargo liner purchase, you will receive a detailed guide that shows, with pictures and writing, how to fit your cargo liner. With the guide, you will receive the Velcro needed for the installation. There is one crucial step to take before you install your cargo liner and that is applying Autoglym Intensive Tar Remover to the plastic parts of the trunk. This removes any silicone buildup which helps the Velcro stick to your trunk, much better. After this step has been carried out, you simply attach the Velcro to the plastic parts of the car, tie the headrest straps around the headrests, and your cargo liner is ready for adventures. As the cargo liner is attached by Velcro, it can be easily taken out the trunk and just as easily kept in, so your car gets the ultimate protection.

Weathertech cargo liners are also tailor-made for your vehicle, but gapping can often be an issue. The installation process is slightly different in that it is only one step. The cargo liner is placed into the base of the trunk with no added layers of security. This can result in the cargo liner shifting around as there are no anchoring points that keep the liner secure. The installation method is quick and efficient, but with no guarantee of security, your cargo liner can shift and your trunk susceptible to damage.

Both the Hatchbag and Weathertech cargo liners are easy to fit into your vehicle. If you prioritise security and optimum coverage, the Hatchbag cargo liner is the way to go. The Velcro strips in conjunction with the well-crafted headrest straps, guarantees a secure cargo liner that won’t move around in your trunk.

Which Cargo Liner is Right for You?

Ultimately, the decision between Hatchbag and Weathertech cargo liners depends on your needs and preferences. We can guarantee the Hatchbag cargo liner will cater to your lifestyle. The Hatchbag cargo liner also offers unbeatable protection, helping out the resale value of your vehicle and crucially, keeping it spotless. Shop our range of cargo liners now and keep your car protected for its lifetime!